Create it Collective

Inspiring humans to get creative & explore Buffalo NY from a different perspective.

  • Home
    • Facebook
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • + Shop Local
  • + Explore Buffalo
  • + Create & Learn

15 Places to Find Unique Gifts in Buffalo NY | The Ultimate Gift Shop List

Shop Local | Shopping

November 29, 2019 by Mariah Magazine

Pin2
Share2
Tweet
Share
4 Shares

Finding and picking out gifts for your family and friends can be overwhelming. You want to pick out something thoughtful & unique, instead of the same old picture frame that’s been regifted 17x.

You can absolutely find a ton of options browsing online, but what about when you want to do it the “old fashion” way and explore a local store for options? We got you.

Where can you find unique gifts in Buffalo NY?!

The list is in NO particular order. We’ve included links to the business’ website or Facebook page so you can easily snag their address and scope out their store hours. Happy gifting 😉

  1. Marilla Country Store:
    • Location: Marilla, NY
    • This one-of-a-kind store, over 160+ years old is one of the oldest businesses in WNY. They offer an incredible selection of fresh bulk foods, candies, gifts, and home décor. Truly a unique country store!
  2. Vidler’s 5 & 10:
    • Location: East Aurora, NY
    • They say “you’ll never know what you’ll find at Vidlers”, and that’s the truth. They have over 75,000 items spread through 4 buildings on 2 levels. It’s a shopping experience you won’t find literally anywhere else. You can spend hours here *which we totally have* and still won’t see everything in this 5 & 10 cent store!
  3. ShopCraft:
    • Location: Buffalo, NY
    • ShopCraft is an artisan collective, fostering a strong community of local artists by offering accessible exposure and promoting local economic growth. In their gallery and gift shop, you can find the work of more than 30 local artists.
  4. A Snails Place:
    • Location: Elma, NY
    • A fabulous gift shop and florist packed with great service and unique finds, promising to be a peaceful and inspirational experience.
  5. Neo Gift Studio:
    • Location: Buffalo, NY
    • Serving the Buffalo community since 1985. The store offers a whole range of items including business gifts, bath and body fragrances, and personal and home accessories.
  6. Tara Gift Shop:
    • Location: South Buffalo, NY
    • Founded in 1980, Tara Gift Shop is WNY’s Original Irish Import shop. Located in the Irish Heritage District of South Buffalo and specializing in Irish goods.
  7. Plain Jayne’s Gift Shop:
    • Location: West Seneca, NY
    • Plain Jayne’s features Buffalo souvenirs, chocolates, premium coffee, Artwork by Joyce, custom canvas prints, Carpentry by Bob, and so much more!
  8. Thin Ice Handmade Gifts from Local Artists:
    • Location: Buffalo, NY
    • Thin Ice opened in March of 2006 to provide a place for local and regional artists to sell their work to the local community. Items include one of a kind jewelry, pottery, handmade cards, hand-blown as well as fused glass, hand-turned wood bowls, hand-sewn leather items, decorative wall art, kaleidoscopes, souvenirs, mugs, wind chimes, hand towels, cutting boards, books and much, much more!
  9. The Perfect Gift Boutique:
    • Location: Clarence, NY
    • The Perfect Gift is a beautiful shop located in the heart of Clarence Center, NY, just outside of Buffalo. Specializing in one-of-a-kind items from local artists as well as unique home decor, gift items, handcrafted and national brand jewelry, seasonal giftware, and more.
  10. Everything Elmwood:
    • Locations: Buffalo, NY & Snyder, NY
    • Everything Elmwood has 2 locations, both equally as awesome. Specializing in handmade gifts from local artists, apparel, prints, decor, pottery, and so much more. This place is a MUST visit for sure.
  11. The Bookworm & BW Gifts:
    • Location: East Aurora, NY
    • The Bookworm originally started out as a discount bookstore but has since expanded into a unique gifting paradise. Shelves and shelves of books, new & used are available along with an entire back room dedicated to gifts of all kinds.
  12. Flicker Gifts:
    • Location: Hamburg
    • Specializing in awe-inspiring gifts, Eden CandleWorks candles, crafted sterling jewelry, natural gems & minerals, and inspirational gifts of all kinds.
  13. Magpie Cards & Gifts:
    • Location: Hamburg, NY
    • Unique card and gift store in the Hamburg Village. It’s been referred to as “basically an upgraded version of a Hallmark store”. They carry eco-friendly/sustainable gift options, as well as name brand items, decor, and specialty items.
  14. The Old Steeple: Primitive Antiques & Gifts:
    • Location: Elma, NY
    • A hundred-year-old church showcasing a mix of primitive antiques, reproductions and handcrafted items. This place is seriously one of a kind.
  15. Baddington Bros Farm Market:
    • Location: East Amherst, NY
    • Badding Bros Farm Market is a family-owned and operated garden center and farm market in East Amherst, NY. The garden center sells a full line of annuals and perennials, as well as gardening supplies, pottery, fountains, and statues. Perfect for all of your plant-based gifting needs!

Have a favorite gift shop from the Buffalo NY area that we missed?

Let us know in the comments!

15 Places to Find Unique Gifts in Buffalo NY | The Ultimate List of Gift Shops
Pin2
Share2
Tweet
Share
4 Shares

Other Posts You Might Like:

5 Ways to Get Creative With Your Spirituality - Create it Collective - Buffalo NY
Buffalo NY Artists to Hire for Your Next Mural| Find Local Mural Painter - Create it Collective
Best Place to Watch the Sunset in Buffalo NY - Create it Collective

Inspiring humans to get creative & explore Buffalo NY from a different perspective.

Community over competition, always.

Learn about us

Popular Posts

Best Cafes to Get Work Done in Buffalo NY | Laptop Friendly Cafes With Free WiFiBest Cafes to Get Work Done in Buffalo NY | Laptop Friendly Cafes With Free WiFi
5 Creative Communities to Get Involved in Buffalo NY5 Creative Communities to Get Involved in Buffalo NY
Where To Buy Indoor Plants in (and around) Buffalo NYWhere To Buy Indoor Plants in (and around) Buffalo NY
Kids Art Classes & Creative Activities in Buffalo NYKids Art Classes & Creative Activities in Buffalo NY
Where to Buy a Real Christmas Tree in Buffalo NYWhere to Buy a Real Christmas Tree in Buffalo NY
Vegan-Friendly Restaurants in (and around) Buffalo NYVegan-Friendly Restaurants in (and around) Buffalo NY
15 Places to Find Unique Gifts in Buffalo NY | The Ultimate Gift Shop List15 Places to Find Unique Gifts in Buffalo NY | The Ultimate Gift Shop List
Buffalo NY Murals: The Ultimate Guide for a DIY Mural Hunt in the CityBuffalo NY Murals: The Ultimate Guide for a DIY Mural Hunt in the City
Where to Paint Pottery in Buffalo NY?Where to Paint Pottery in Buffalo NY?
Pottery Classes in Buffalo NY | Where to Learn CeramicsPottery Classes in Buffalo NY | Where to Learn Ceramics

Categories

Recent Posts

  • 5 Ways to Get Creative With Your Spirituality
  • Buffalo NY Artists to Hire for Your Next Mural| Find Local Mural Painter
  • Best Place to Watch the Sunset in Buffalo NY
  • Buffalo NY Murals: The Ultimate Guide for a DIY Mural Hunt in the City
  • Kids Art Classes & Creative Activities in Buffalo NY

Archives

  • December 2020
  • September 2020
  • July 2020
  • February 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019

STAY UPDATED ON ALL THINGS BUFFALO NY

Want to be part of the Create it Collective Community? We’d love to have you!  

Just pop your info in the form below and we’ll keep you in the loop about new lists, guides, and collaboration opportunities.

Please wait...

Thank you for signing up!

[instagram-feed]

HOME

ABOUT

BLOG

CONTACT

Instagram Pinterest Facebook

Inspiring humans to get creative & explore Buffalo NY from a different perspective. Community over competition, always. 
Create it Collective © 2019 | Website by Mariah Magazine | Privacy Policy + Terms & Conditions

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT